05false100true score desc 2gaptrue5mapcontentxmltrue50object_type_i,object_type_i_lookup,coverage_period_mt,geographic_area_mt,geographic_coordinates_mt,author_role_mt,contributor_role_mt,org_id_mt,org_role_mt,supervisor_mt,supervisor_id_mi,supervisor_id_mi_lookup,fields_of_research_mi,fields_of_research_mi_lookup,display_type_i,display_type_i_lookup,seo_code_mi,seo_code_mi_lookup,copyright_i,license_i,license_i_lookup,oa_compliance_t,oa_notes_t,grant_id_t,funding_body_t,description_of_resource_t,software_required_t,project_description_t,keywords_mt,project_name_t,project_id_t,isdatasetof_mt,isdatasetof_mt_lookup,notes_t,date_dt,xsd_display_option_mi,xsd_display_option_mi_lookup,file_downloads_i,created_date_dt,updated_date_dt,research_program_mt,title_t,depositor_i,isderivationof_mt,assigned_user_id_mt,assigned_group_id_mi,assigned_group_id_mi_lookup,isdatacomponentof_mt,isannotationof_mt,author_id_mi,author_id_mi_lookup,alternative_title_mt,pid_t,publisher_t,author_mt,contributor_mt,contributor_id_mi,contributor_id_mi_lookup,refereed_i,series_t,journal_name_t,newspaper_t,conference_name_t,book_title_t,identifier_mt,edition_t,subject_mi,subject_mi_lookup,place_of_publication_t,start_page_t,end_page_t,chapter_number_t,issue_number_t,volume_number_t,conference_dates_t,conference_location_t,patent_number_t,country_of_issue_t,description_t,date_available_dt,language_mt,phonetic_title_t,language_of_title_mt,translated_title_t,phonetic_journal_name_t,translated_journal_name_t,phonetic_book_title_t,translated_book_title_t,phonetic_newspaper_t,file_attachment_name_mt,translated_newspaper_t,phonetic_conference_name_t,translated_conference_name_t,issn_mt,isbn_mt,isi_loc_t,prn_t,output_availability_t,na_explanation_t,sensitivity_explanation_t,file_attachment_content_mt,org_unit_name_t,org_name_t,report_number_t,sequence_i,genre_t,genre_type_t,formatted_title_t,formatted_abstract_t,parent_publication_t,convener_t,ismemberof_mt,ismemberof_mt_lookup,link_mt,link_description_mt,rights_t,views_i,scopus_id_t,thomson_citation_count_i,gs_citation_count_i,gs_cited_by_link_t,scopus_citation_count_i,status_i,status_i_lookup,first_author_in_document_derived_t,first_author_in_fez_derived_t,ands_collection_type_t,start_date_dt,end_date_dt,access_conditions_t,extent_t,contact_details_email_mt,contact_details_physical_mt,loc_subject_heading_mt,depositor_affiliation_i,surrounding_features_mt,condition_mt,style_mt,period_mt,category_mt,subcategory_mt,structural_systems_mt,adt_id_t,subtype_t,language_of_parent_title_t,proceedings_title_t,file_description_mt,herdc_code_i,herdc_code_i_lookup,herdc_status_i,herdc_status_i_lookup,institutional_status_i,institutional_status_i_lookup,herdc_notes_t,follow_up_flags_i,follow_up_flags_i_lookup,follow_up_flags_imu_i,follow_up_flags_imu_i_lookup,scopus_doc_type_t,scopus_doc_type_t_lookup,wok_doc_type_t,wok_doc_type_t_lookup,conference_id_i,total_chapters_t,publisher_id_i,translated_proceedings_title_t,native_script_title_t,roman_script_title_t,native_script_book_title_t,roman_script_book_title_t,native_script_journal_name_t,roman_script_journal_name_t,native_script_conference_name_t,roman_script_conference_name_t,total_pages_t,native_script_proceedings_title_t,roman_script_proceedings_title_t,language_of_book_title_mt,language_of_journal_name_mt,language_of_proceedings_title_mt,doi_t,author_count_t,collection_year_dt,location_mt,building_materials_mt,architectural_features_mt,interior_features_mt,sherpa_colour_t,ain_detail_t,rj_2010_rank_t,rj_2010_title_t,rj_2012_rank_t,rj_2012_title_t,rc_2010_rank_t,rc_2010_title_t,herdc_code_description_t,score,citation_t1true60 (judicial dialogue AND status_i:(2)) 6display_type_idisplay_type_i_lookup_exactkeywords_mftdate_year_tauthor_id_miauthor_id_mi_lookup_exactauthor_mftjournal_name_t_ftsubject_misubject_mi_lookup_exactgenre_type_t_ftismemberof_mftismemberof_mt_lookup_exactsubtype_t_ftscopus_doc_type_t_ftscopus_doc_type_t_lookup_exact(_authlister_t:(1)) AND (status_i:(2)) 34232014-09-01T00:00:00Z1342014-12-19T23:19:27ZLas referencias recíprocas entre el Tribunal Europeo y la Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos: ¿de la influencia al diálogo? = The cross references between the European Court of Human Rights and the Inter-American Court of Human Hights: from the influence to the dialogue?bibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-91-7040El artículo intenta aclarar los resultados de una investigación empírica sobre las referencias o citas recíprocas entre el Tribunal Europeo de Derechos Humanos (TEDH) y la Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos (Corte IDH), reconocibles en la motivación de sus resoluciones.
Muchos estudios han destacado que el uso de precedentes extranjeros (o «extrasistémicos») no se limita a los Tribunales nacionales, sino afecta también a los Tribunales internacionales. Todavía, es frecuente un abuso de la apelación de «dialogo judicial» para estas prácticas: además, faltan datos empíricos completos y normalmente se encuentran algunos ejemplos bastante casuales.
El artículo presenta los resultados de una investigación extensiva y completa sobre las decisiones de los dos Tribunales en los años 1987-2012, para verificar si verdaderamente hay algún dialogo entre los dos sistemas. La investigación sigue el método ya experimentado en estudios empíricos sobre el uso de precedentes extranjeros para los tribunales constitucionales, que está integrado al mismo tiempo para un análisis cuantitativo y cualitativo.
La investigación no muestra evidencias de un verdadero dialogo entre las dos instituciones, sino de una convergencia jurisprudencial en varias materias.The article aims to analyze the mutual references made in their judgments by the European Court of Human Rights and the Inter-american Court of Human Rights.
Previous studies on circulation of foreign precedents have been showing that the use of foreign or «extra-systemic» precedents is not a phenomenon limited to national courts, but does also affect international courts. Nontheless, the notion of «judicial dialogue» is often abused, and the interactions between courts are hardly proved through empirical data but rather through seldom examples.
The article presents the results of a general and systemic research on the case-law of the two courts in the period between 1987 and 2012, to verify if there is some kind of «judicial dialogue» or «cross-fertilization» between the two systems. The research follows the methodology previously applied in empirical studies on the use of foreign precedents by constitutional courts, which consists of both a quantitative and a qualitative analysis.
The research did not show any evidence of the existence of a real «dialogue» between the two courts, but rather of a «convergence» among their jurisprudence in several fields.06172<a class="citation_author_name" title="Browse by Author Name for Groppi, Tania" href="/fez/list/author/Groppi, Tania/">Groppi, Tania</a> and <a class="citation_author_name" title="Browse by Author Name for Lecis Cocco-Ortu, Anna Maria" href="/fez/list/author/Lecis Cocco-Ortu, Anna Maria/">Lecis Cocco-Ortu, Anna Maria</a> . (<span class="citation_date">2014</span>) <a class="citation_title" title="Click to view : Las referencias recíprocas entre el Tribunal Europeo y la Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos: ¿de la influencia al diálogo? = The cross references between the European Court of Human Rights and the Inter-American Court of Human Hights: from the influence to the dialogue?" href="/fez/view/bibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-91-7040">Las referencias recíprocas entre el Tribunal Europeo y la Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos: ¿de la influencia al diálogo? = The cross references between the European Court of Human Rights and the Inter-American Court of Human Hights: from the influence to the dialogue?</a>. RecordArtículo de revistaPublishedhttp://udcdata.info/021523DerechoUniversidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia (España). Facultad de Derecho. Departamento de Derecho PolíticoGroppi, TaniaLecis Cocco-Ortu, Anna Mariabibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-91-7040bibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-91-7040esDocumento.pdfbibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-91bibliuned:Setopenairebibliuned:SetarticuloRevista de derecho político. Año 2014, n. 91Set de openaireSet de artículohttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0Licencia Creative CommonsGroppiAcceso abierto0.79293984