012false100true score desc 2gaptrue5mapcontentxmltrue50object_type_i,object_type_i_lookup,coverage_period_mt,geographic_area_mt,geographic_coordinates_mt,author_role_mt,contributor_role_mt,org_id_mt,org_role_mt,supervisor_mt,supervisor_id_mi,supervisor_id_mi_lookup,fields_of_research_mi,fields_of_research_mi_lookup,display_type_i,display_type_i_lookup,seo_code_mi,seo_code_mi_lookup,copyright_i,license_i,license_i_lookup,oa_compliance_t,oa_notes_t,grant_id_t,funding_body_t,description_of_resource_t,software_required_t,project_description_t,keywords_mt,project_name_t,project_id_t,isdatasetof_mt,isdatasetof_mt_lookup,notes_t,date_dt,xsd_display_option_mi,xsd_display_option_mi_lookup,file_downloads_i,created_date_dt,updated_date_dt,research_program_mt,title_t,depositor_i,isderivationof_mt,assigned_user_id_mt,assigned_group_id_mi,assigned_group_id_mi_lookup,isdatacomponentof_mt,isannotationof_mt,author_id_mi,author_id_mi_lookup,alternative_title_mt,pid_t,publisher_t,author_mt,contributor_mt,contributor_id_mi,contributor_id_mi_lookup,refereed_i,series_t,journal_name_t,newspaper_t,conference_name_t,book_title_t,identifier_mt,edition_t,subject_mi,subject_mi_lookup,place_of_publication_t,start_page_t,end_page_t,chapter_number_t,issue_number_t,volume_number_t,conference_dates_t,conference_location_t,patent_number_t,country_of_issue_t,description_t,date_available_dt,language_mt,phonetic_title_t,language_of_title_mt,translated_title_t,phonetic_journal_name_t,translated_journal_name_t,phonetic_book_title_t,translated_book_title_t,phonetic_newspaper_t,file_attachment_name_mt,translated_newspaper_t,phonetic_conference_name_t,translated_conference_name_t,issn_mt,isbn_mt,isi_loc_t,prn_t,output_availability_t,na_explanation_t,sensitivity_explanation_t,file_attachment_content_mt,org_unit_name_t,org_name_t,report_number_t,sequence_i,genre_t,genre_type_t,formatted_title_t,formatted_abstract_t,parent_publication_t,convener_t,ismemberof_mt,ismemberof_mt_lookup,link_mt,link_description_mt,rights_t,views_i,scopus_id_t,thomson_citation_count_i,gs_citation_count_i,gs_cited_by_link_t,scopus_citation_count_i,status_i,status_i_lookup,first_author_in_document_derived_t,first_author_in_fez_derived_t,ands_collection_type_t,start_date_dt,end_date_dt,access_conditions_t,extent_t,contact_details_email_mt,contact_details_physical_mt,loc_subject_heading_mt,depositor_affiliation_i,surrounding_features_mt,condition_mt,style_mt,period_mt,category_mt,subcategory_mt,structural_systems_mt,adt_id_t,subtype_t,language_of_parent_title_t,proceedings_title_t,file_description_mt,herdc_code_i,herdc_code_i_lookup,herdc_status_i,herdc_status_i_lookup,institutional_status_i,institutional_status_i_lookup,herdc_notes_t,follow_up_flags_i,follow_up_flags_i_lookup,follow_up_flags_imu_i,follow_up_flags_imu_i_lookup,scopus_doc_type_t,scopus_doc_type_t_lookup,wok_doc_type_t,wok_doc_type_t_lookup,conference_id_i,total_chapters_t,publisher_id_i,translated_proceedings_title_t,native_script_title_t,roman_script_title_t,native_script_book_title_t,roman_script_book_title_t,native_script_journal_name_t,roman_script_journal_name_t,native_script_conference_name_t,roman_script_conference_name_t,total_pages_t,native_script_proceedings_title_t,roman_script_proceedings_title_t,language_of_book_title_mt,language_of_journal_name_mt,language_of_proceedings_title_mt,doi_t,author_count_t,collection_year_dt,location_mt,building_materials_mt,architectural_features_mt,interior_features_mt,sherpa_colour_t,ain_detail_t,rj_2010_rank_t,rj_2010_title_t,rj_2012_rank_t,rj_2012_title_t,rc_2010_rank_t,rc_2010_title_t,herdc_code_description_t,score,citation_t1true60 (Historical law AND ismemberof_mt:bibliuned\:DerechoPolitico\-2014\-89 AND keywords_mt:(Derecho) AND status_i:(2)) 6display_type_idisplay_type_i_lookup_exactkeywords_mftdate_year_tauthor_id_miauthor_id_mi_lookup_exactauthor_mftjournal_name_t_ftsubject_misubject_mi_lookup_exactgenre_type_t_ftismemberof_mftismemberof_mt_lookup_exactsubtype_t_ftscopus_doc_type_t_ftscopus_doc_type_t_lookup_exact(_authlister_t:(1)) AND (status_i:(2)) 34232014-01-01T00:00:00Z3692014-07-02T23:19:27ZRevisión, trascendencia constitucional y memoria histórica = Appeal by review, constitutional relevance and historical memorybibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-89-6025La posibilidad de revisar y, en su caso, declarar la nulidad de las sentencias del franquismo ha sido y, continua siendo, una cuestión muy controvertida política, doctrinal y también jurisprudencialmente.
Este trabajo analiza con ojos críticos el criterio mantenido recientemente por el Tribunal Supremo en esta materia al denegar la autorización para la interposición del recurso de revisión basándose en la supuesta carencia de objeto del recurso porque cuando la Ley de Memoria Histórica declara la injusticia e ilegitimidad de dichas condenas las priva de eficacia jurídica. Una respuesta que, como se explicará en las siguientes páginas, vulnera el derecho a la tutela judicial efectiva en dos de sus dimensiones concretas: el derecho de acceso al proceso y, el derecho a un resolución fundada en derecho; pero que afecta también indirectamente al derecho a la presunción de inocencia.
Una forma gráfica de presentar esta crítica es exponiéndola a través de un caso concreto; el de una víctima paradigmática del franquismo, el poeta Miguel Hernández y su familia a quienes inexplicablemente ambos tribunales les hayan cerrado las puertas.Appeal by review (revisión) against judgment, that has already gained res judicata, is an extraordinary remedy based upon reasons of Justice. When this appeal by review is used for the annulment of judgments of Franco dictatorship, this well known statement had been in the past, and has been nowadays, a very controversial issue politically, doctrinally and jurisprudentially.
This critical paper analyses the Spanish Supreme Court’s opinion uphold in this matter to deny the previous authorisation, which is requiered for filing the petition of the appeal by review. The Supreme Court based its decision on a alleged lack of purpose for this review procedure because when the Historical Memory Law declares injustice and illegitimacy of those sentences, this Law deprives them also of their legal effect. This answer, as we explained in the following pages, violates the due process (as a fundamental right of effective judicial protection) in two of its specific dimensions: the right of access to the courts and judicial procedure and the right to a decision based in law, but also indirectly affects the presumption of innocence.
In order to illustrate this review we decided to do it through a specific case, which involves a paradigmatic victim of Franco’s regime, the poet Miguel Hernández and his family to whom the Spanish Supreme Court and the Constitutional Court have closed inexplicably their doors for Justice.06842<a class="citation_author_name" title="Browse by Author Name for Oubiña Barbolla, Sabela" href="/fez/list/author/Oubiña Barbolla, Sabela/">Oubiña Barbolla, Sabela</a> . (<span class="citation_date">2014</span>) <a class="citation_title" title="Click to view : Revisión, trascendencia constitucional y memoria histórica = Appeal by review, constitutional relevance and historical memory" href="/fez/view/bibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-89-6025">Revisión, trascendencia constitucional y memoria histórica = Appeal by review, constitutional relevance and historical memory</a>. RecordArtículo de revistaPublishedhttp://udcdata.info/021523DerechoUniversidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia (España). Facultad de Derecho. Departamento de Derecho PolíticoOubiña Barbolla, Sabelabibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-89-6025bibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-89-6025esDocumento.pdfbibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-89bibliuned:Setopenairebibliuned:SetarticuloRevista de derecho político. Año 2014, n. 89Set de openaireSet de artículohttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0Licencia Creative CommonsOubiña BarbollaAcceso abierto5.36015834232014-01-01T00:00:00Z6332014-07-02T23:19:27ZLa libertad de creencias en la Constitución japonesa = Freedom of belief in the japanese Constitutionbibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-89-6020La Constitución de Japón (1947) garantiza el derecho a la libertad de creencias, sistematizado a lo largo de su articulado. El sistema, influenciado notoriamente por la Constitución norteamericana, presenta notas características de la idiosincrasia japonesa que resultaran de interés para el lector occidental. En el presente trabajo se realiza un estudio sobre la garantía de esta libertad (tanto en su vertiente ideológica como religiosa) a través del análisis de la evolución histórica del sistema, de la revisión de la doctrina científica más aplaudida y de la jurisprudencia más relevante sobre la materia.The Constitution of Japan (1947) guarantees the right to freedom of belief, which is systematized in several articles of the text. Having received a notorious influence from the U. S Constitution, the system shows some characteristic features that should be of interest to western scholars. In this work a study on this freedom (both on its ideological and religious sides) is carried out by analyzing the historical evolution of the system and by revising the most praised academic theories as well as the most relevant case law on this matter.05692<a class="citation_author_name" title="Browse by Author Name for Pedriza, Luis" href="/fez/list/author/Pedriza, Luis/">Pedriza, Luis</a> . (<span class="citation_date">2014</span>) <a class="citation_title" title="Click to view : La libertad de creencias en la Constitución japonesa = Freedom of belief in the japanese Constitution" href="/fez/view/bibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-89-6020">La libertad de creencias en la Constitución japonesa = Freedom of belief in the japanese Constitution</a>. RecordArtículo de revistaPublishedhttp://udcdata.info/021523DerechoUniversidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia (España). Facultad de Derecho. Departamento de Derecho PolíticoPedriza, Luisbibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-89-6020bibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-89-6020esDocumento.pdfbibliuned:DerechoPolitico-2014-89bibliuned:Setopenairebibliuned:SetarticuloRevista de derecho político. Año 2014, n. 89Set de openaireSet de artículohttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0Licencia Creative CommonsPedrizaAcceso abierto5.27926122222222222